1883 bros is it worth watching?

1883 bros is it worth watching?

If you haven't seen enough westerns in your life, then yes.

it's good, yea. Tim McGraw is a A tier actor.

Then I shall continue.

If I haven't watched Yellowstone, will this hold up, or do they assume foreknowledge.

Not gonna spoil it but it's extremely cucked at the end.

It's a prequel, but without a lot of callbacks since most of the story takes place on the journey to Yellowstone not at the ranch itself.

just skip every monologue the main mary sue does and you won't be so numb to the retardation and might just enjoy it, a lil.

Yellowstone not required, it's actually a way shittier show

It's so bad. Story is lame. Everyones acting is bad. The sets look so cheap. The main girl looks like she could be on some Disney show and doesn't fit the time period. Nothing looks authentic. Sam Elliot still plays the same character like he always has. 1/10. Taylor Sheridan is the biggest hack ever

Yellowstone not required

Good.

I'm not interested. I only watch period westerns and Americana. Anything contemporary holds no escapism value for me.

The main girl looks like she could be on some Disney show and doesn't fit the time period. Nothing looks authentic. Sam Elliot still plays the same character like he always has.

Sam Elliot is the only actor in that image with an old world face. Miss 1950s westerns where they had a whole stable of interesting, typecast character actors with lived experience stamped all over their faces.

Sam Elliot still plays the same character like he always has.

What is wrong with that? He does it spectacularly and fits the image of an old western cowboy perfectly? Maybe, they should Denzel Washington to give the western more flavor.

I don't mind sam Elliot but the whole show was still a drag to watch. If this is considered good western these days then we've fallen off big time.

doesn't the cute blonde get redded?

If this is considered good western these days then we've fallen off big time.

Sadly, it is. Is it actually a good western compared to the rest? Fuck no.
yes she is a mudshark so skip all her scenes/narrations to save yourself

mudshark

fucking lol

She gets blonded first but her white boyfriend dies of Sam Elliott's incompetence like 99% of the wagon train.

1887 is better.

I just can't believe someone could watch that piano scene(the one where the main girl just happens to find that piano in the middle of the field and plays it) and not think this is the most sappy shit imaginable. The whole show felt like this. The romance was still unbearable to watch. This did not feel like a western at all

If you can appreciate nonsense for what it is, sure. Faith Hill and Isabel May are the picture of "LOOK!! I'M ACTING!" and the latter's voice overs are trite and cliche to the point of comedy.
And without getting into anything episodic, the overarching story is just plainly retarded. As if no one writing the show has ever seen a map of the US (or period railway maps which you easily find online, let alone in a library), they take a train (which is supposedly a large expense for them) from Tennessee to Fort Worth and then decide to walk to Montana or just walk as far north as they can? Literally just adding 1100 miles of peril and expenses to their journey instead of taking a more direct route, like a train from Chicago to Cheyenne and then the Bozeman trail or even better a boat up the Missouri river. We have no indication that the Duttons are impoverished or wanted fugitives or anything so there is no reason at all for them to take such a circuitous route.

Anon, it's not the 90's-00's anymore where we can get multiple seasons of legit red-blooded western tv shows. If you want to watch modern western tv shows you have to accept you will deal with 70% slop and have to appreciate the 30% or go watch deadwood for the 50th time.

If you want to watch a young girls journey fucking her way across the great plains before tragically dying then go ahead.

They were supposed to be going to Oregon. They were on the Oregon Trail, not the Montana Trail. They wound up in Montana because their guide was suicidal and didn't give a fuck about doing the job they hired him for.

This and 1923 had one too many

looks directly into the camera and explains why men and white people bad

for me, and i'm brown as shit

I was going to tell that anon it was a story of the Oregon trail but its probably some foreigner who never played the game as a child nor taught our history.

All of Sheridan's shows are just soap operas for childless women and homosexuals.

doesn't realize that straight men date women and sometimes you have to watch their bs shows to get sex and keep them happy

Just say you are doomer incel already.

That seems like a very miserable life.

Sheridan definitely played it.

Is that how "Yellowstone" ended?

Basically yes. I flourished abit. But in the end they give it away to the local indian tribe so that the greedy people after the land don't get it for a ski resort or airport

Or picrel, which was a better western than both of the westerns you named.

Harrison Jones

Ford? And I thought the main character was the guy trying to get back from Africa. He's the only one I remember anything about from the first season.

Lol, didn’t an Indian killing one of the Duttons and then getting by one of the Duttons start the conflict between the two of them?

The second season is just utter retardation, the first season is watchable, the second might be one of the worst seasons of television ever.

There was already a conflict when the Indian killed the forgotten Dutton. The shootings just intensifies it for awhile.

No. I dropped it as soon as sam eilliot started simping so hard he was going to kill men who were rightfully mad at a women for stealing their shit. Gay af

Everyone very quickly forgot about that guy.
I think they mentioned him like one other time in the show past the 1st season.
He was a brother, and a son, and some totally forgettable dude also. I always have to laugh about this fact.

I liked the journey home story in the first season. Not because it was well written or acted but because it was so fucking ridiculous.

He was the best son, as far as continuing the ranch. You'd think that Daddy Dutton would mention this to his other, shittier children on a regular basis.

You would think that, but Sheridan has said himself that his westerns are inspired by Larry McMurtry's Lonesome Dove series, which start off with a fictionalization of the Goodnight-Loving Trail from Texas to Cheyenne (and later Montana). Charles Goodnight both shows up in and is the inspiration for one of the main characters in LD; he is a savior in 1883 and his ranch (the Palo Duro Canyon) again becomes a setting in 1923.

Also Sheridan was a trust fund kid, he wasn't playing any public school computer games.

That show was only kino for the first s1 then turned into a film about a legitimate mudshark.
It's late and I swapped names but yea he saves the day after queen bee did all the heavy lifting. It's literally just them 2 vs 30 at the end.

trust fund kid, he wasn't playing any public school computer games.

You are wrong, his class had 10 computers to play it for 25 kids while mine had 1.

Ok, but in the show they all said they were going to Oregon. Sam Elliott's last scene is on a beach in Oregon.

Just watching that scene I knew somewhere in my heart that he wasn't gonna be in the 1883 (2)

the entire yellowstone universe boils down to 1 lesson

fighting over dirt is retarded and pointless

Bravo Sherridork.

It's one of those those that starts to mock you with how woke it gets half way through
Like it becomes almost comical
the white chick, after her white male lover dies, starts fucking injuns under tornados. It's ridiculous. Some troon gooned hard writing this trash.

Sure, but we already knew they were going end up in Montana anyways. Going from Forth Worth to Portland instead of Bozeman is 600 miles longer and through a lot of mountain passes. Even then it probably would've been cheaper, quicker and safer for them to take the transcontinental railroad (1869) to the west coast than furnishing the wagon, draft animals. food etc. for that trip.