No film youtuber is nearly as good as he is

You're right, Adam Johnston has pretty much set the gold standard for film criticism on YouTube. What's amazing is that he's managed to stay this good for so long because he balances humor and depth in a way that most critics can't. His ability to break down films—whether it’s dissecting cinematography or storytelling—while still keeping things entertaining is what makes his content so consistently engaging. Plus, he’s not just following trends; he sticks to his unique voice and approach, which has built him such a loyal following. He’s also got this perfect mix of wit and insight, and he’s not afraid to call out even the most beloved movies when they deserve it, which adds a lot of credibility to his opinions. Over the years, his taste has only matured, and his editing style, community engagement, and genuine passion for film have kept him at the top. It’s that consistency, along with his authenticity, that’s allowed him to stay relevant and respected in the YouTube film space for so long.

Can you even refute him?

this has to be a troll that you needed a youtuber to explain this

his synecdoche new york vids are kino but this mfer is taking longer than the actual movie took to write, pitch, direct and market

well anon you could always just watch his clips channe- oh...nevermind

He hasn't made a good video in a while so I stopped watching him

Pretty sure YMS has just completely given up on making the synecdoche new york videos at this point

He's sick and dying. Something in his intestines.

Well at least he made some good money and invested it well, didn't piss it all away on quick and easy pleasures like a complete tit.

I don’t care about his reaction shit
I don’t care about his reviews
I don’t care about his multi hour discussion videos
I don’t care about his dumb commentary videos with his gay friends
The only thing he was good at, and the only thing people liked him for, was his ~20-30 minute YMS videos dunking on shitty movies that were funny and well put together.
He doesn’t really make those anymore, so there is no point in watching him

What unlimited access to the internet and a lack of non-online or non-parasocial relationships does to a mofo.

He never even finished his Synecdoche, New York analysis

isn't this guy a fag?

I wanna start my channel, but I'm too lazy. And every time I come across some retard posting a video from one of the usual retards, my mind goes "who cares about this fucking tard's opinion?", so I assume it would be the same if people posted my videos here.

Is that Adam Johnston from YMS (YourDogSuckMyCockdotORG) who is a notorious dog rapist and puppy molester?

He’s a fucking piece of shit faggot and 99.99% of his jokes are “he he I wud fuck that lmao” “im so edgy >:)“

He's sick and dying

He's been saying that for a decade

this movie wasn't bad in any way but I didn't bother finishing it, 6/10

such valuable opinions!

Why does he talk like that now? He didn't sound so nasally and whiny like ten years ago. Is he doing a character or something? It must be intentional.

He's got nose cancer

Why Nick Fuentes donating to YMS thoughbeit

fucker thinks people care about his video game opinions

Lmao!

Why is the Kiwi farms guy using Anon Babble meme arrows?

He also fucks dogs

Yes and?

When was his last upload?

Hey guys Olivia here

be a gay fag who gets his asshole railed by nigger cock multiple times daily for money

develop colon cancer and fecal oncontinence due to your faggot ass getting railed so often

amazing, amazing, bravo!

All of his health issues just sounds like he probably has AIDS

if killing animals is justified then so is having sex with them
Simple as.

Hello YMS (YourDockSucksMyCock)

PRIDE!
BRAVE!
SLAAYY~~

point the error in my argument.
if the industrial slaughterhouses are a-okay then how some zoofag having his way with a dog isn't?

I mean it's either that or heavy alcohol abuse.

good

He's another friend sim like RLM just not as big. Plus he has the furry community backing him. Adam is a sick piece of shit.

I remember when this retard claimed Citizen Kane introduced the world to 3-act narrative structure in cinema. How do people take this weird dysgenic seriously?

One is done out of necessity for food and medicine (contrary to what retards believe, humans are omnivores and not all can survive on a plant-only diet).
The other is literally just to give more dopamine to mentally ill and degenerate freaks.

Hello YMS also known as YourDogSucksMyCockdotORG, fucking animals is immoral and illegal you nasty homosexual zoophile pervert

Adam completely buckbroke him.

Because the industries which rely on animal abuse are deeply entrenched into our economy and cannot be dismantled without totally collapsing it meanwhile a dogfucker is abusing an animal for his own sexual gratification. One situation is a convoluted trolley problem in which great suffering is unavoidable and the other simply choosing not to sodomize a chihuahua because you want to coom.

The raping of dogs is a pathway to many powers some consider unnatural.

It's so obvious they didn't like eachother from the beginning. I don't know why they thought it was a good idea to start a podcast together. Ralph's self imposed humiliation ritual was just the straw that broke the camel's back.

How do people take this weird dysgenic seriously?

He advertised himself relentlessly on furry and lgbt forums to build a fanbase when he was starting out as another dime-a-million Plinkett clone. He reads every thread here and his homepage is his kiwi farms thread. The guy was never taken seriously he just was early and spammed himself.

I don't know why they thought it was a good idea to start a podcast together.

It was three retards each thinking the other two retards would make them look less retarded by comparison. Ralf was never gonna win that one on those terms, he has too much gabagool in him.

Dog fucker

daaaaaaaam his walking death reviews where the funniest shit ever, shame he dosent do more things similar because of youtube copyright and his health

Every single time a thread on this guy is made there’s like ten+ mentions of “dog”.

Why?

Mark English was the only good thing about this guy

He has sex with dogs

I do feel bad for Ralph because he clearly had no idea what he was getting himself into.
Trying to have a discussion/debate with an autist is one of the most infuriating things on the planet.

So why did this guy crash out anyway?
All 3 of them stopped making film review videos:

dogman is sick and depressed

IHE went off the grid completely with no explanation

Ralph seems completely dead inside, phoning in his new videos so hard that he's virtually unrecognizable

It's sad because Ralph clearly was the only one of the three who had any talent at all. Dogman is the smartest of the bunch, but he's only good at analysis. IHE is a total blank who just lucked out on a funny premise, he's like a construction worker who randomly stumbled into film criticism and has no clue what he's doing or any passion for the artform.

What is especially strange is that basically everyone from the 2nd wave of YouTube film criticism who were all directly inspired by the Plinkett vids crashed and burned so spectacularly after just a couple years, meanwhile RLM is still going (they seem a little fatigued too, but to be fair they're like 50 year old men now).

Because he defends bestiality. It is his banana up the ass moment.
After he's died from aids in a couple years before he's finished all the videos he promised to do, that's all he is gonna be remembered for.

Dogman is the smartest of the bunch, but he's only good at analysis

Hell fucking no, Dogfucker had, and I think still has, a clear knack and talent for editing. His YMS humor almost entirely relies on editing. And I don't mean how he inserts memes or cutaway gags, just the general pacing of the review.
The other non-YMS videos are edited by someone he hires, so it never translates.
I don't know how he could be good at analysis when he thinks that I'm Thinking of Ending Things takes place in the janitor's head and is some kind of obscure and hard-to-grasp revelation.

gives up youtube to try to make it as a legit filmmaker

just made a by the numbers black & white student film that wasn't very good

very clear after all his years of film school he has nothing to show for it simply due to lack of talent

is forced to come crawling back to youtube

gets depressed because his dreams are dead

falls into weed/alcohol as coping mechanisms

the few reviews he does release are low quality slop where hes sleeping through the narration

still does the podcast but barely offers any commentary and is sometimes silent for 30+ minutes

quits because everyone points out how disinterested he is and questions why hes even there

just releases a bland movie review every few months

Not sure why he hasn't just killed himself at this point.

Nobody cares about movies anymore, so nobody cares about movie criticism either.
NPC normies will watch whatever slop they're advertised and everyone else know that most of them are bad now and will just pirate the one or two movies a year that peak there interest.

He literally, quite fucking literally, has sex with dogs. Literally. Yes.

faggot ass cornholing dog fucker

IHE is the only one who ever said anything insightful about the films they were discussing. That's how it played out every time, Ralph would just say something menial like "the cinematography was good" or "the set design was good", YMS would go off on an autistic contrarian tangent about some minor nothing that nobody else cared about or noticed, and IHE would actually discuss the movie.

dogs can consent to sex

dropped. This guy needs to be investigated

the few reviews he does release are low quality slop where hes sleeping through the narration

Yea I clicked on one of his videos a little while back a noticed that. He looked and sounded like he was a fucking chemo patient.

His sense of humor shines in videos like Justin Time where he intersperses stupid plot details with awkward cast interviews where they try to explain the rules of the world

don't forget that yms is a failed musician

"If the dog didn't want to suck my cock then why did he keep licking the peanut butter that was on it hmm?" - YMS unironically

Oh?
I never listened the the podcast, I only watched their respective channels. I guess IHE is at a disadvantage there since his whole shtick is to review movies that are basically unwatchable. Can you name one interesting thing he said? Not pulling your leg, I'm genuinely curious.

damn this shit sucks lmao
youtu.be/06DVwGD-G60?si=JIqo1PG8P17Va1zZ
youtu.be/ozOJim9IJRg?si=ue9J_9naTc4J3bEP

It's bad, but so is 90% of successful music. I don't see why this couldn't be popular if performed by someone who can sing.

I don't have anything specific in mind, I haven't watched the podcast in a few years. But generally what I mean is that IHE was the only one that would push the conversation toward discussing any subtext or meaning in films. And also he'd actually put in legwork and research things that the other hosts had no clue about.

I don’t have any examples, I listened to a handful of episodes years ago, but I agree with what that other anon said.
Ralph only ever spoke on the most basic level shit, (“I liked the part where…”, or “I agree”) and honestly seemed like he was stoned or some shit most of the time. I could have a better discussion with some rando off the street. And he’s supposed to be the one that’s the “movie maker”….
YMS was just typical YMS
IHE seemed to actually try and put some effort into it.

21 mentions to be exact

so it's actually true? i knew he was a fag with a nig boyfriend, but he ACTUALLY fucked a dog? like how do people know this? did he admit to it in a video?

I think he just said that if you're okay with eating meat you should be okay with fucking dogs, that they're on the same moral level.

The dog claimed he was abused by YMS in one of his woofstreams

see
he went on an autistic rant comparing eating meat to having sex with animals as animals cannot consent to either action. no reasonable human being without skin in the game would go to these lengths to argue this point which leads many to believe hes into bestiality(hes also a furry).

How does he keep winning?

uuuughhghhgghhh

He has more energy and feels like a good filmmaker in his movie reviews. But his actual “movies” or attempts at making movies are so fucking boring and bland. What the fuck dude? I liked you but now I don’t even know if you suk or not

Making movies is actually really hard. Maybe you're talented at editing, or lighting, or soundmixing, or writing, but few people can do it all - and if you're not sponsored by someone who has already recognized your talent, it's incredibly expensive to fill in those gaps in your production. Granted, the YouTuber films I've seen over the years seem to be really bad, especially the scripts. You, I, or any random anon in this thread could probably do a better job with that particular aspect. But in terms of the overall production, we'd probably fail just as badly or worse.
When Sean Baker pointed his iphone at those two trannies and made his debut, it seemed like a door had opened for scrubs. But with the more elaborate production on his 2nd film it became immediately clear that he already had exceptional talent from the start and it was just somewhat obfuscated by the gimmick.
There's a 1/10000000 shot that a lot of funding will just fall into your lap, like that time that Sandberg guy suddenly got to make capeshit flicks based off a single random YouTube short because his last name happened to sound extremely Jewish and none of the studio execs actually bothered to double-check.

That's YMS when he cums inside of a dog anus

Anon, please. He's a bottom. He's the one taking dogknot

ah yes the autistic dogfucking fagtuber that dedicated years of his life to making a kimba the lion fucking video only autistic retards like himself care about. turbo autists r' us

Does yms really post videos of himself getting railed by nogs?

this shit was so funny to me

"why is this annoying nerdy sounding editor talking at the end of the video?"

Months later

"oh great he's Olivia now"

Weeks later

"oh great now his big boobed fursona is talking to me"

Unironically trannyvoice, his friend group is all putting on fake voices 100% of the time and it's rubbing off on him

There’s some (possibly deleted) Twitter alt account of his out there

That nigga was getting barebacked and bussy busted.

IHE still makes some vids though. Very depressing to see this though, I used to watch these guys all the time bak in 2017-2018

For an actual, factual, tl;dr answer:
He said if you can jack off animals for money (breeding, meat industry) you should be able to jack off animals for their pleasure.
It bugs me specifically because I think "he sucks dogs off" is substantially funnier than "he fucks dogs", and actually fits with his stance.

He's not, though. he knows absolutely nothing about film history. youtube.com/watch?v=BYWNFwwOqYQ

thinks that I'm Thinking of Ending Things takes place in the janitor's head

and is some kind of obscure and hard-to-grasp revelation.

So is it or isn't it?

DOG FUCKER

yms is a failed musician

More successful than 99.99999% of all musicians throughout history

The animation tis actually pretty cool though, really nice backgrounds. the song is ok actually

Aside from dogfucking, aside from being a faggot, aside from being Canadian, aside from having a piss poor work ethic, he's not a good film critic. He's decent at pointing out flaws with a film that are more tangible such as plotholes, but when it comes to explaining why a movie is good or going beyond the literal parts of a film, he fails. He's no Armond White and I say that completely unironically.

woah some washed up has beens covered his song now this is epic

yes having a global pop star cover the song you wrote in your bedroom then getting an article about that song in Rolling Stone is the furthest thing from a "failed musician"

If you like this guy you should unironically go to home depot and buy a length of rope to strangle yourself with. He might be the most degenerate e-celeb on the internet. Biggest pseud, mentally ill freak on the planet. Would love to cave his skull in.

His videos are funny (back when he actually made videos) though. I don't care how much of a mentally ill degen he is. Why would his mental state be in any way relevant to me?

i got the pics but i can't post them here

Is it autistic or kino to watch the entire lion king video and want more?

He might be the most degenerate e-celeb on the internet.

Nah he doesn't use his efame to fuck pornstars

He still makes videos? I haven’t been recommended anything in years.

Remember his voice was really whiney and he fucked dogs or some shit or argued dogs could consent to being fuck or something

Blocks your path

It's autistic and straight up worthy of a mentally deficient individual.

The gender reveal will be so glorious

The sacred sexts...

>IHE went off the grid completely with no explanation

He's lazy and occasionally makes some shitty multi hour ramble about a video game cause it gets him views.

Yeah idk why he cares about Destiny 2, of all games, so much. Who gives a fuck? It's literally the most boring soulless shit imaginable, and he's dedicated his entire YouTube channel to covering it. Bizarre

Thanks to Anon Babble I've seen this dogfucker getting slammed in the arse by some fat black dude
It was everything I thought it could be

one person liking your song who happens to be famous is not a notable accomplishment. I don't put much stock in the opinions of pop stars anyways and it's funny that you do.

It's objectively wrong to call him a failed musician though. His music has significant attention. You can say his music is bad, but you can't say he's a failed musician. I hate Taylor Swift's music but that doesn't make her a failed musician

if that is funny to you I encourage you to come back to it in 5 years when you're 16.

pic related is an actual film professor, and unlike the dog fucker, he actually posts videos regularly, isn't a mopey redditor with shitty uninformed opinions, and doesn't avoid a movie just because it's older than 50 years.

YMS is really just one or two scandals away from being an iDubbz or Nick Rekieta tier lolcow.

His music has significant attention

so does doug walker's. it's not hard to get people to listen to you when you've already cultivated an audience through other means. joji is an example of a successful e celeb turned musician. people listen to his music because they like it, not because he was le meme man on the internet. how many people have bought dogfucker's albums? I would guess not very many.

his music tho

It doesn't matter, and no one cares.
Unless he made a career switch and is working full time as a musician, then he's a meme hobbyist, not an actual musician.

*releases one video a year*

Failing as a musician means either

he doesn't have enough talent to provide the world with a one-of-a-kind piece of music

he steals full compositions and calls them his own

Dogfucker being guilty of both
His music being good or bad has nothing to do with failure

thought that the house that jack built was a straight drama and all the humor was unintentional

Thinks Citizen Kane invented plot structure when called out he moves the goal post

Thinks death proof’s plot structure is unique despite it being identical to Psycho and it’s many clones

Thinks love you daddy color scheme is to replicate older films and doesn’t understand that it’s a homage to woody Allen films

Unironically thinks anyone who likes Welles or Kurosawa only likes them because they makes them look smart

can’t comprehend that there is more than one type of editing style

docks Happiness a point because he thinks that the pedophile didn’t suffer enough

Reviews Ayka a film that he’s only seen 40 minutes of. Then complains that it won best actress at Cannes.

Thinks Kevin Smith is trying to prove something with Tusk despite it just being a shitty podcast adaptation for the fans

Needs for everything to be explained and doesn’t understand the concept of magical realism

misunderstood the satirical nature of Showgirls

doesn’t get the fact that the Cloud is Sils Maria superhero scene is supposed to look as ridiculous as possible to highlight the juvenile nature of capeshit

thought that Hawaii was Japan in Godzilla and criticized it because people spoke english in the scene

Thinks most editing equals best editing then moves the goal post when called out and says he just thought the categories were made to include blockbusters at the oscars despite the category first winner being in 1934 and was a documentary

His fans are a bunch of pseuds that legitimately think Kaufman Is one of the best directors ever

Thinks Uncle Boonmee experience was akin to viewing a slideshow of nice locations

Thinks David Lynch films don’t have any meaning or purpose to their strangeness

His review of the Turin horse boiled down to “I get it life sucked in the olden days do something”

fucks dogs

he steals full compositions and calls them his own

Dogfucker being guilty of both

explain

>Thinks Citizen Kane invented plot structure

He didn't say that though. He said that Citizen Kane invented the plot structure that subsequently became the standard for films.

you can't just copy the melody and arrangement of other song, change the lyrics and pretend to be a musician

posts himself getting dicked down by some fat nigger

I don't ever care to watch this guy again.

Yeah John Williams is such a failure

He didn't say that

He said that Citizen Kane invented plot structure

How is that even true? Citizen Kane has a very atypical plot structure since it's constantly cutting back and forth between the present and flashbacks

>Unironically thinks anyone who likes Welles or Kurosawa only likes them because they makes them look smart

whooooooaaaa buddy
Imagine thinking this and then simultaneously gassing up overrated jews like Kaufman.

What if people like those old school directors because their movies are just straightforward good movies and not pretentious and annoying self-wankery?

This guy is really great actually. Too bad he turned into a streaming whore.

Anon didn't say that

That's 90% of music

Anon didn't say that

even doe I'm quoting him directly

Whooaa, if John Williams (man who composed the SW theme) is a failure, then what does that make doggyfucker with zero credits and no resume?

directly

Wrong. Read the post again.

YMS fans aren't very bright people, anon

John Williams

change the lyrics

have you even HEARD music once anon?

what song has he copied?

Are you talking to a mirror?

from 1447 to 2019, all of them

inventing a plot structure is not inventing plot structure as a concept SAAAAR

literally made me stop caring about his work though as others have pointed out its been 5+ years since the kimba video

It started narrative structures that now is pretty much every movie.

All these things you're familiar with seeing, in terms of progression or act structure, et cetera, those didn't really exist if you go back far enough.

It was just people fucking around with a camera and doing funny things or weird things.

This is literally what he said.

I wonder if part of the decline of these kinds of reviewers is people just getting tired of the "this FUCKING sucks" content farm outside of specific franchises like Star Wars or capeshit. People seem more interested in lofty video essays about how something is actually meaningful and in depth, even if the vids in question are more bland than white bread.

It started narrative structures that now is pretty much every movie.

Yes, that is exactly what I said. What is the confusion?

The only videos that remotely interest me are the ones where some guy with maybe 1-10k subscribers makes a 30+ min video about some really obscure or cult movie/show/book that I watched/read that no one else seems to care about.

You're doing what I did and selecting only the parts of the quote that proves your point, ignoring the context, which proves when I did it I was right.

No, you selectively edited what I said to fit your narrative, I directly quoted what you posted. I didn't address the rest of it because it's not relevant to the discussion. If you feel differently feel free to explain your thinking. Otherwise I'm not sure what you want from me.

If you feel differently feel free to explain your thinking.

It contextualises what he means.

Tanks 4 the quality post stranger

I wonder if Lion King part 2 comes about before the next Synechdoche New York part.

I didn't close to finish that video. Really sounded psychosomatic up-to where I gave up though.

I can only withstand so much cringe bros

True. And none of it even implies that he believes Citizen Kane invented plot structure.

You know he's a woman because he was an attention whore from the start.

Wow what a terrible design, let me fix it

Except for the last part

constantly highlights his own stream comments

It goes without saying but hes such a faggot.

U probs hit the nail on the head. Ralph is probably a good editor, but to actually ho out and get the footage for his movie he probably sucks

His Kimba video is autism kino, the Lion King review felt like an afterthought in comparison.

That would only be true if you believed that films invented plot structure, which they didn't.

YMS believes films before Citizen Kane didn't have progression or act structure, they were just people doing weird or funny things with a camera.

watches 1st 20 minutes on x2 speed while looking at twitch chat

"yeah i noticed the auto peaked for .000001 seconds so thats a 6/10 closer to a 5 than a 7"

This is called moving the goal post anon

If abortion is justified...

It's literally what he said

i have seen some funny vids by him and i know he's a furry. what are some other cringe-inducing fax about him. anyone care to help a nigga out?

he posts images of himself being fucked in the ass by a black man on twitter
no im not exaggerating any of that

Which is different than what was said here

in terms of progression or act structure, et cetera, those didn't really exist if you go back far enough

Jesus.
Probably would have gotten away with it if it didn't come out in 40s.
What a fucking midwit.

It is his banana up the ass moment.

TAA would probably say much of the same thing. And it wasn't the banan that ended him either.

This is called cope anon.

He said movies before citizen kane was just goofing around in front of a camera

Yes, you dumb fucking faggot there is a character limit. You have to condense YMS golden quotes to fit everything.
Did you know that it was in two parts at some point?

How so?
That does not mean it invented plot structure. Two separate statements.
I'm not talking about the whole post, just the particular quote. Obviously.

Love that one.

hes not a normalfag. normies are all nigger cattle retards

At some point being constantly confused like this isn't a witty rebuttal and just makes you come off as a retard.

Yeah, at this point it just feels like he's stuck in a sunken-cost fallacy. I feel like his autism has become too powerful and craves too much. While I did enjoy his Lion King remake YMS, I think it's fair to say that being concise and knowing what points to cut out is important as well. I wouldn't have these critiques if he posted smaller videos more frequently. I've watched him for years and will sometimes watch the highlights channel here and there (the one with the dude who's a pink wolf with massive tiddies). I think he needs a vacation from streaming

I don't know how someone can look at a group of people and how they just coincidentally mostly all ended up as trans. It sure does look like the Super Smash Bros Melee community got hit by a virus b/c 7 out of 10 people there are troons

holy shit, this isn't even about lacking film knowledge, it's just a lapse of critical thinking. Is he aware that novels are a thing?

That does not mean it invented plot structure. Two separate statements.

Two -possibly separate- absolutely retarded statements.

I don't actually care. Can you refute the argument?

silence zoomer wigger

it's an argument about nothing

I never claimed the statement he made was true, I said that anon mischaracterized the statement. See the difference?

just the particular quote. Obviously.

Which was shortened to fit under 2k. In essence, that's what he said, which he then had to backtrack like the fucking pseud retard that he was.
What is the difference between "it started" and "it invented," by the way in this context? Can you please elaborate without sliding into semantics? Nothing is miscategorization, that's what he said.

Why would that be the case?

Probably the easiest to refute argument you've made.

He literally destroyed his gut biome by eating shit.

nothing based about trying to cancel drinker like the faggot he is that dograper

Which was shortened

No it wasn't, it was misrepresented.

In essence, that's what he said

You are the one backtracking and moving the goalposts when you say this.

What is the difference between "it started" and "it invented," by the way in this context

Because the original post offered no context. It said plainly, that he claimed Citizen Kane invented plot structure, which is an untrue assertion. "Invented" has a very clear meaning, and it does not apply here. If you meant otherwise, that's a failing of your own lexicon, not of my understanding.

I thought he did a much better job in season 2, not sure why he's getting so much hate about being ugly

It's a false equivalency.

No it wasn't, it was misrepresented.

No, it wasn't. The whole quote can indeed be shortened to "CK invented plot structure" because that's what he meant.

You are the one backtracking and moving the goalposts when you say this.

You have zero idea what any of these words mean, I fear.

It started, meaning before CK this plot structure was not used, making it the first one to do so.
What did YMS mean by it then, that changing "started" to "invented" somehow changes meaning and characterizes it differently? You can't start a movie screenwriting trend if it already exists. So why saying "it invented the trend" gives it a different meaning?
Why wouldn't 'invented' be the appropriate synonym for 'started'?

why are you so excited about some literal homo faggot? whats his best video?

having a global pop star cover the song you wrote

Literally only because she watches his videos

got to meet her too

Cool.
Granted it looks like it was a streaming only song so he doesn't really get any credit, but her hearing his song and wanting to cover it is more recognition than the majority of indie musicians can ever hope for.

His videos were funny.

did he review videodrome or something? what was debbie looking for?

very fucking true

The whole quote can indeed be shortened to "CK invented plot structure" because that's what he meant

That's not correct. None of the quotes posted so far indicate that he believes Citizen Kane invented plot structure.

You have zero idea what any of these words mean, I fear.

You are by definition moving the goalposts and also backtracking when you reframe the argument from "He said that Citizen Kane invented plot structure" to "He essentially said that Citizen Kane invented plot structure". If you were eating a slice of pizza and said, "this pizza is bad", and I claimed that you said "pizza is bad", would you accept this as an accurate truncation of your words? In essence they're the same statement.

before CK this plot structure was not used

Something must be invented before it is capable of being used. This statement is a direct contradiction of your argument.

So why saying "it invented the trend"

It was never claimed he said it invented the trend of the thing. It was claimed he invented the thing itself. Which is false.

Why wouldn't 'invented' be the appropriate synonym for 'started'?

It can be. But the claims that "Citizen Kane invented plot structure" and "Citizen Kane started plot structure" are both equally misrepresentative of what he stated.

He thinks because we eat meat we can fuck dogs in the ass

This, it's not like a film review, even a well written and researched one, takes THAT long to make. He got burnt out and just wants to move on

*It was claimed he said it invented the thing itself

that's some 'suffering is better than death' attitude. he must be a fan of china then.

???

Oh, so he's lgbt. Now I get why he's so popular here.

he still makes tezukafag beaners seethe

Honestly? The only based dogfucker.

are the dog allegations true?

I think the only evidence is that he has argued it, destiny-style

That's not correct. None of the quotes posted so far indicate that he believes Citizen Kane invented plot structure.

youtube.com/watch?v=BYWNFwwOqYQ
Take it away, Adam.

You are by definition moving the goalposts and also backtracking when you reframe the argument from

Honey, nobody claimed it's a direct quote in the original post. You can't start a trend that already existed and was invented by someone else for the movie before CK. Which is the point of the whole fucking ridicule behind this quote.

If you were eating a slice of pizza and said, "this pizza is bad", and I claimed that you said "pizza is bad", would you accept this as an accurate truncation of your words?

This literally has nothing to do with what we are talking about. He brazenly says that before CK no one had ever implemented these structures into the movies. And only starting from CK did nebulous progression and act structure come into their own.
Never before, just gaffers running with a camera.

Something must be invented before it is capable of being used

I know, right? Almost like you are free to say Adam said that CK invented plot structure.

It was never claimed he said it invented the trend of the thing.

"It started narrative structures" is absolutely equivalent to "it invented plot structure." It's the same thing.

It can be.

Thank you. So it is being used as such. Why are we having an argument then? Did you get exiled from Adam's Reddit or something?

Dog.

he doesn't know shit about movies and he fucks dogs.

nobody claimed it's a direct quote in the original post

Nobody said it needed to be a direct quote.

You can't start a trend that already existed

To start a trend of a thing, the thing itself must first exist. In other words, it must be invented.

This literally has nothing to do with what we are talking about

It's called an analogy.

He brazenly says that before CK no one had ever implemented these structures into the movies

Implementation necessarily implies existence.

Adam said that CK invented plot structure.

Westworld is the first movie to use CGI. Did Westworld invent CGI? This should be a simple yes or no answer.

It started narrative structures

We were talking about the trend. Stop backtracking and moving goalposts.

So it is being used as such.

No. If you read further in that post I've already explained why you're wrong.

So much this.

didnt this guy rape his dog or something

Kek this is the only thing I know him for
I never even liked that movie but his videos about it made me appreciate it

He started making and selling movie-themed onions candles on etsy and random NYC malls with his mom.
Very depressing stuff.

the dog consented

Onion candles? What?

forgot pic

Nobody said it needed to be a direct quote.

You are literally here squeaking that he said "started" instead of "invented." And that it somehow makes a giant difference when it doesn't.

To start a trend of a thing, the thing itself must first exist. In other words, it must be invented.

Not according to YMS, just a gaffer with a camera, remember?

It's called an analogy.

And I said it makes no sense since this isn't an issue of definite articles.

Implementation necessarily implies existence.

It literally doesn't. He says, "Those didn't really exist," so in YMS's own words, it doesn't imply it.

Did Westworld invent CGI?

In movies? Yes. You could say it. Because this is what we are talking about: plot structure in MOVIES being invented by CK. And how retarded this statement is.
An equivalent of saying Jurassic Park "started" CGI in movies and before Jurassic Park it didn't really exist.
Just 3D balls dancing around the screen.

We were talking about the trend

No, we are not. I used the word trend. YMS does not use the word trend in his whole-ass quote; he unmistakably says the conventional plot structure was just not there before CK. It doesn't matter how you put it: "invented" or "started." The meaning is the same.

If you read further in that post I've already explained why you're wrong.

All I see is a retarded semantics dispute that doesn't improve or change anything YMS actually said.

Not true, jacking them off was part of it but he specifically mentioned "letting a dog hump his butt". He really, really wanted Fido to bury his bone in a legal setting

In movies? Yes. You could say it.

I accept your concession

I forgot he had a fursuit.

Ever since Scott died there has been zero reason to watch any of his channels anymore.
Bee Larry King

bruhhh

Ralph clearly was the only one of the three who had any talent at all

Really? I admit that I only listened to a few episodes but I came away genuinely wondering if Ralph had a learning disability

crash out

TALK
LIKE
A
HUMAN
BEING

What concession, goober?
Citizen Kane did not "invent" "start" "establish" "design" any conventional or trendy plot structure for movies that Dogfucker mentions and that movies use today.
He says this because he saw 3 fucking movies that came out before 1950s in his life at that point. He has zero frame of reference.

Wait?! This whole time you thought Adam was right? Jesus Christ. Are you aware there is a conga line of John Ford movies that Welles was looking at for inspiration?
The only thing Citizen Kane arguably "invented" is the fucking low angle of the camera by putting an operator into the hole they sawed off in the set.

people whose only hobby is watching films are just fat depressed alchies. thats why people come up with pretentious dork elitist complexes about it.

if you took film critics or people that talk film on youtube, and put them against any other conceivable demographic, they would be the fattest and least healthy by far. they could probably do less pushups on average than people with cancer.

So(y)

Lion King part 2 fucking when

Imagine paying thousands of dollars for this nightmare fuel.

Has a fursuit ever looked good? Even if you’re a furry I feel like you’ve got to realize the actual suits look horrible.

gets fucked in ass by black men and posts pictures of it on twitter

He and the BBC broke up last year after Scoot died

OH N-

has an image of him having sex with a black man

be the best part of the watchalongs

die

hold up, that's not varg?

mofo

*dofo

Apparently Merk made a channel where he goes by Doby now.

fuckin sucks that he's gone

Did they ever confirm how this dude died?

He worked on his music for such a long time and he never realized how bad his singing is.

eh, at least he still makes based videos, even if it takes a long time for them to come out

IHE is completely different on his podcast with his real life friends. He's a surprisingly likable and funny guy when he doesn't have to manage complete autists.

Channel's a shell of its former self, it's Joever now that he injured himself.

Things started going downhill when Mark left

Man I miss watching IHE videos, his musically one aged like fine wine
youtube.com/watch?v=zX1OdAZoXsU

Sadly it remains a mystery. We will never know what caused this young healthy person to suddenly have a heart attack for no reason. Many such cases.

vax

Conspiracy theorist punks fuck off

Mauler did better and more frequent Frodo-type "Why didn't they x" reviews before he also stopped posting videos because podcast money was too nice.

Ralph had some promising short films as a kid. They were clearly aping Scorcese but there was an undeniable passion and energy behind them. He just lost that spark as he grew up and fried his brain with alcohol and drugs. The weekly humiliation ritual on Sardonicast didn't help his confidence either.

I saw he was in the Last of Us 2 on HBO, when did he get into acting?

Ralph was the best of the 3 at his peak.

Henson's cause of death was not revealed. Following his death, Henson's family asked for donations to the SPCA or any cat rescue organization.[13]

Clot shot confirmed.

food is a need, intercourse isn't

Shame that he hasn't made much of a name for himself.

So I can kill and eat you, but rape is off the table? Ok

His Saw X discussion was pretty fun, but I unsubscribed a while back once I saw him take nigger dick up the ass

fucker of dogs

Yea it really seems like he dropped to a room temperature IQ

the only straight guy amongst a pack of uberhomos

I'm guessing AIDS by osmosis

YMS aged pretty badly.